Off-Topic > Music
Orchestral Submissions-Temporary Holding Area
Winter:
No worries. I'll admit that I've been slacking on my Music Theory studies.
Dude:
--- Quote from: SlowPokemon on August 29, 2011, 04:00:46 AM ---What's wrong with being Slow?
--- End quote ---
Lol, you're so funny.
SlowPokemon:
--- Quote from: Olimar12345 on August 29, 2011, 05:40:44 AM ---I don't think we should be accepting every submission that we get just cus' someone posted it in the submission board-we should crack down more on reviewing sheets for acuracy and playablilty.
--- End quote ---
Amidst all the misspellings, you have a solid point, one that Winter WILL NOT LISTEN TO >_> (sorry Winter)
JUST BECAUSE DAHANS ARRANGES IT AND IT SOUNDS GOOD DOES NOT MAKE IT PLAYABLE OR A GOOD ARRANGEMENT (sorry dahans)
I realize I'm probably pissing multiple people off by posting this, but I've had this burning in my throat for quite a while now. I've tried to get this point across about dahans' Ruby/Sapphire medley, but all I got was "go ahead and submit a replacement then." Playability is far more important than the arrangement "sounding good." The sound of the piece isn't going to do anyone much good if no one can play it. I don't even care about the pieces being difficult, as long as they're not freakishly unplayable/hard.
I realize that an arrangement takes a long time, and it's hard work, and they're difficult to get perfect sometimes. But that's when you listen to feedback, not submit it anyway. Sometimes you have to swallow your pride.
There. I'm done with my ranting. I just can't stand requesting a piece, getting something impossible in return, and nothing being done about it. So I give up on that piece, or have to request it again, which ends in "hey there's already one on the site" or "hey [insert name] has done this."
It's not that I don't appreciate people arranging, I don't want anybody to get pissed and stop arranging or leave or anything, but we really need to start scrutinizing the sheets for these problems. (Mine included.)
Brassman388:
Slow, if it means anything, I fully support you and your cause.
If you want me to give that piece a go, send me a link or something.
SlowPokemon:
oh nonono you misunderstand, I'm not mad about that piece specifically, just the general thing.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version